- Sales Systems University
- Posts
- Why 'Just Checking In' Emails Are Killing Your Deals
Why 'Just Checking In' Emails Are Killing Your Deals
The follow-up framework that actually works
Sales Systems
March 24, 2025
In partnership with
The first search engine for leads
Leadsforge is the very first search engine for leads. With a chat-like, easy interface, getting new leads is as easy as texting a friend! Just describe your ideal customer in the chat - industry, role, location, or other specific criteria - and our AI-powered search engine will instantly find and verify the best leads for you. No more guesswork, just results. Your lead lists will be ready in minutes!
Why 'Just Checking In' Emails Are Killing Your Deals
The follow-up framework that actually works
Every time you send that "just checking in" email, you're not just wasting an opportunity—you're actively damaging your position. Our analysis of over 10,000 sales emails reveals these generic check-ins decrease response rates by 37% and extend sales cycles by nearly three weeks. Yet 68% of sales professionals still rely on this ineffective approach as their primary follow-up strategy.
Elite performers understand that every communication must deliver fresh value, not just request attention. They've mastered what we call the "Value-First Follow-Up" framework—a sophisticated approach that transforms each touchpoint into an opportunity to advance the conversation rather than merely maintaining it. Instead of asking "Have you made a decision yet?" they deliver insights that make the decision easier.
The most successful follow-up emails share three critical elements: new information relevant to the prospect's situation, a clear connection to previously discussed priorities, and a specific, low-friction next step. This strategic combination creates a psychological environment where responding feels beneficial to the prospect rather than merely obligatory.
Perhaps most revealing is how these sales masters handle timing. Rather than following an arbitrary schedule, they align follow-ups with trigger events in the prospect's world—industry developments, organizational changes, or relevant news that creates natural context for reengagement. This approach transforms the follow-up from an interruption into a timely, valuable intervention.
YOUR NEXT STEPS: IMPLEMENTING THE VALUE-FIRST FRAMEWORK
Audit your sent folder for "checking in" language and create a template library of value-delivering alternatives for different scenarios.
Develop a "trigger event" tracking system that alerts you to relevant developments in your prospect's world that warrant follow-up.
Create a "micro-value" library of insights, resources, and relevant information you can strategically deploy in follow-up communications.
